Shot tracking only works if you actually do it. Every golf app promises stats and Strokes Gained analysis, but the data behind those numbers is only as good as how consistently it gets captured, and consistency depends on how much friction there is in the moment. A tracking method that's perfect on a practice round but gets skipped on hole 14 when you're focused on your score doesn't produce usable data.
That's why the number of ways an app lets you track matters more than any single method being clever. A golfer who hates typing into a phone might track everything with a button click. A golfer who wants zero interaction might prefer a tag tap or a fully automatic mode. A golfer with a smartwatch might not want their phone out at all. One rigid tracking method works for some golfers and gets abandoned by everyone else.
18Birdies relies on Smart Tracking, a Premium-only feature that uses your phone's GPS movement to detect pauses and infer shot locations, then asks you to confirm score, putts, and penalties after each hole. Pairing an Apple Watch adds Auto Swing Detection for better accuracy, but that's Apple Watch only, and Smart Tracking isn't available on the free tier at all.
The Grint includes a shot tracker on its free tier, along with GPS maps and basic scoring, but tracking is manual: you log shots as you go. Smartwatch shot tracking exists for Apple Watch and Wear OS, but the full smartwatch experience, scoring, shot tracking, and aerial maps together, requires The Grint Pro. There's no automatic GPS-based detection and no dedicated tracking hardware.
Hole19 covers more ground: manual tracking is available to everyone, and its Intelligence subscription adds auto shot detection that identifies shots automatically and asks you to confirm them, similar in concept to 18Birdies' approach. Hole19 also supports full shot tracking, club selection, and lie editing from an Apple Watch or Wear OS watch. It's a solid two-and-a-half methods, manual, automatic via subscription, and smartwatch, but still no dedicated hardware.
Golf Pad covers all of that ground and adds two methods none of the others have:
| Golf Pad | 18Birdies | The Grint | Hole19 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Manual in-app tracking | Yes, free | Yes | Yes, free | Yes, free |
| GPS-based automatic detection | Not the primary method | Smart Tracking, Premium only | Not available | Auto shot detection, Intelligence subscription |
| Dedicated tracking hardware | Golf Pad TAGS, $119 (NFC tags) | Not offered | Not offered | Not offered |
| Hands-free remote button | Golf Pad Click, $29.99 | Not offered | Not offered | Not offered |
| Smartwatch tracking | Apple Watch, Wear OS, Samsung Galaxy Watch | Apple Watch only (Auto Swing Detection) | Apple Watch, Wear OS (full features Pro only) | Apple Watch, Wear OS |
| Distinct tracking methods available | 4 | 2 | 2 | 3 |
If you already skip manual tracking because typing after every shot breaks your rhythm, that's exactly the gap Golf Pad TAGS and Golf Pad Click are built to close, one by removing the phone from the equation entirely with a tap, the other by replacing typing with a single click. 18Birdies and Hole19 both offer a phone-in-pocket automatic option, which works well for golfers who don't mind a subscription and don't need certainty on every shot, since GPS-based detection depends on pauses in movement rather than a direct signal from the swing itself. The Grint keeps things simplest with a free manual tracker, which is honest and easy to understand, but offers no path to hands-free tracking at any price.
Which golf app has the most shot tracking options?
Golf Pad, with four distinct methods: manual in-app tracking, NFC hardware tracking via Golf Pad TAGS, hands-free tracking via the Golf Pad Click button, and smartwatch tracking across Apple Watch, Wear OS, and Samsung Galaxy Watch.
Does any competitor offer tracking hardware like Golf Pad TAGS?
No. 18Birdies, The Grint, and Hole19 all track shots through the phone or a smartwatch. None currently offers a dedicated hardware accessory for automatic club and shot detection.
Is automatic shot tracking free on any of these apps?
Not fully. The Grint's shot tracker is free but manual. 18Birdies' Smart Tracking and Hole19's auto shot detection are both gated behind a paid subscription. Golf Pad's manual tracking is free, while its automatic options (TAGS and Click) are one-time hardware purchases rather than subscriptions.
What's the difference between Golf Pad TAGS and Golf Pad Click?
TAGS are NFC tags that attach to each club; you tap your phone to a tag before a shot to log the club and distance automatically. Click is a Bluetooth button you press instead, letting you track a shot or putt with a single click without touching your phone at all.
Do any of these apps track shots automatically from a smartwatch?
Golf Pad, The Grint, and Hole19 all support shot tracking from a smartwatch. 18Birdies only offers automatic swing detection through an Apple Watch specifically, as part of its Premium Smart Tracking feature.
Subscribe for early access to promotions, feature announcements & more.
